Copiague's Favorite Grilled Cheese Spot

Melted
Perfection

Artisanal grilled cheeses crafted with love, paired with craft cocktails in the heart of Copiague.

Explore Our Menu (833) 698-2483
15+
Signature Sandwiches
4.9
Star Rating
1026
Montauk Hwy
Our Story

More Than Just a
Grilled Cheese

Grilled Cheese Society — Unpublished started with a simple idea: what if we took the humble grilled cheese sandwich and elevated it to an art form? Located in the heart of Copiague on Montauk Highway, we've created a space where comfort food meets craft culture.

Every sandwich is handcrafted using locally sourced ingredients, artisanal breads from nearby bakeries, and cheeses selected for their flavor profiles. Our bar program features craft cocktails that complement our menu perfectly, making us the ideal spot for lunch, dinner, or a night out.

Locally Sourced

Fresh ingredients from local farms

Craft Cocktails

Signature drinks to pair with every meal

Open Daily

Serving from 11am to 10pm

Made with Love

Every sandwich is crafted with care

Grilled Cheese Society interior
4.9
Average Rating
Testimonials

What Our Guests Say

"The best grilled cheese I've ever had! The truffle mushroom is absolutely divine. The atmosphere is warm and inviting — perfect for a casual dinner or a night out with friends."

M
Maria S.
Copiague Local

"I bring all my out-of-town guests here. The grilled cheese is elevated beyond belief, and the cocktail menu is creative and delicious. A true hidden gem in Long Island!"

J
James T.
Islip Resident

"The mac and cheese grilled cheese is a game-changer! Crispy on the outside, gooey on the inside. The staff is incredibly friendly and the vibe is always upbeat. My new favorite spot!"

A
Ashley R.
Bay Shore Regular

Ready for the Best
Grilled Cheese of Your Life?

Visit us at 1026 Montauk Hwy in Copiague, or give us a call to place an order. We can't wait to serve you!

Call (833) 698-2483 Get Directions
Contact Us

Visit Us Today

We're located in the heart of Copiague on Montauk Highway. Stop by for a sandwich, a cocktail, or just to say hello!

Address

1026 Montauk Hwy
Copiague, NY 11726-4902

Hours

Monday – Sunday
11:00 AM – 10:00 PM

Send Us a Message

Message Sent!

Thank you for reaching out. We'll get back to you within 24 hours.

Is this your business? Claim your website
Your own domain includedLive in minutes, edit anytime
Claim my website